Violation ID |
Occurred Date |
Violation Type |
(-) Violation Description |
Corrective Action |
Status |
Classification |
Source |
1140636 |
01/04/2025 |
DMON |
The minimum monitoring requirement for EFF-002 pH and temperature (3/week within a week with a federal holiday) was not met for the week ending on January 4, 2025. While the City originally scheduled for monitoring to occur early in the week, the City had to reschedule for the contract laboratory (Fruit Growers' Laboratory) to conduct EFF-002 pH and temperature monitoring on January 2-4, 2025 due to operational challenges. The City coordinated with their contract testing laboratory on January 2nd in an effort to ensure the testing would be completed as scheduled that week and was provided assurances that the sampling had been completed and the pH measurements were within range. On January 27th, the contract lab communicated that despite this being scheduled in advance, the lab's field sampler missed the third sample that week on January 4, 2025 and instead collected it on January 5, 2025. This sample date fell outside of the weekly period and thus, only two samples for pH and temperature were collected at EFF-002 that week. |
The week ending January 4th was the final week that the City planned for the contract laboratory to collect field measurements at EFF-002. During November and December 2024, the City prepared City operations staff, its metering equipment, and a quality assurance-quality control manual to start collecting the EFF-002 measurements themselves and prevent further non-compliance. January 6, 2025 was selected as the start date for City staff to take over EFF-002 monitoring because this followed scheduled City office closures during the holidays. Now that the City is conducting this testing, it does not expect this type of scheduling error to occur in the future. |
Violation |
U |
eSMR |
1139558 |
12/10/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 9.5 SU at EFF-002. |
After receiving notification of the pH exceedance by the City's contract laboratory, operational staff were able to cease discharge to the river within 30 minutes of the measurement being taken. Flow continued to be diverted to the reclamation system until the following day when process control sampling showed the cooling pond pH to be within the acceptable range again. In response to the December 10, 2024, pH exceedance, the City made operational changes to blend water from the cooling pond with fresh dechlorinated effluent prior to discharging to San Joaquin River. This operational change was implemented on December 23, 2024. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1139557 |
12/06/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Minimum limit is 6.5 SU and reported value was 6.3 SU at EFF-002. |
Originally, this measurement was thought to be a result of a sampling error. After investigation by the City, the result was confirmed to be valid and was thus reported as an exceedance. Because of this delay, no immediate operational changes were made to the discharge. Corrective action taken as a result of the December 6, 2024, pH exceedance, the City made operational changes to blend water from the cooling pond with fresh dechlorinated effluent prior to discharging to San Joaquin River. This operational change was implemented on December 23, 2024. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1129071 |
05/23/2024 |
CAT2 |
Chlorine, Total Residual 1-Hour Average (Mean) limit is 0.019 mg/L and reported value was 0.57 mg/L at EFF-001. |
The closed SBS dosing valve was reopened upon discovery. Additionally, the causes of this violation have been discussed with CTF operations staff and staff have been trained on proper protocol for SBS dosing and valve controls. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1126624 |
03/31/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Minimum limit is 6.5 SU and reported value was 6.3 SU at EFF-001. |
The setpoint error was corrected upon discovery and has been correctly set to 6.5 SU. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1126621 |
03/28/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 9.1 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1126616 |
03/27/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 9.3 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1126617 |
03/26/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 9.3 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1126615 |
03/25/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 9.3 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1126613 |
03/22/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 9.3 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1126614 |
03/21/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 9.3 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1126606 |
03/20/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 9.3 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1126620 |
03/14/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 9.1 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1126619 |
03/13/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 9.2 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1126623 |
03/12/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 9.3 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1126622 |
03/11/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 9.4 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1126618 |
03/08/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 9.6 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1126612 |
03/07/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 9.6 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1126625 |
03/06/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 9.6 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1126609 |
03/05/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 9.6 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1126611 |
03/04/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 9.7 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1126608 |
03/01/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 9.6 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1126610 |
03/01/2024 |
CAT2 |
Chlorine, Total Residual 1-Hour Average (Mean) limit is 0.019 mg/L and reported value was 0.038 mg/L at EFF-001. |
The City regrets this violation having occurred and has implemented additional SCADA controls and operations staff training to prevent this from happening in the future. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1126607 |
03/01/2024 |
CAT2 |
Chlorine, Total Residual 1-Hour Average (Mean) limit is 0.019 mg/L and reported value was 0.197 mg/L at EFF-001. |
The City regrets this violation having occurred and has implemented additional SCADA controls and operations staff training to prevent this from happening in the future. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1125418 |
02/29/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 9.6 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1125420 |
02/28/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 9.4 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1125427 |
02/27/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 9.1 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1125417 |
02/26/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 9.3 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1125425 |
02/23/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 8.7 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1125423 |
02/22/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 8.6 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1125426 |
02/21/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 8.6 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1125422 |
02/20/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 8.8 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1125419 |
02/19/2024 |
OEV |
pH Instantaneous Maximum limit is 8.5 SU and reported value was 8.9 SU at EFF-002. |
The City is evaluating ways to operate the cooling ponds in the immediate future to prevent these violations. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1125416 |
02/04/2024 |
CAT2 |
Chlorine, Total Residual 1-Hour Average (Mean) limit is 0.019 mg/L and reported value was 0.041 mg/L at EFF-001. |
The City regrets this violation having occurred and has implemented additional SCADA controls and operations staff training to prevent this from happening in the future. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1122936 |
11/13/2023 |
Order Conditions |
Filter effluent turbidity exceeded 0.2 NTU for 6% of the 24-hour period on 11/13, violating the recycling specifications. |
On November 14, it was discovered that one of the modules in MBR Train 1 caused the exceedance and this module was taken out of operation. This module remains out of operation until additional repairs can be made. Effluent turbidity did not exceed the Recycling Specifications for the remainder of the reporting period after these actions. Despite these turbidity challenges, the CTF continued to achieve adequate disinfection, with effluent total coliform measuring <1.8 MPN/100mL on November 13, 2023. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1121482 |
09/14/2023 |
Order Conditions |
Filter effluent turbidity exceeded 0.2 NTU for 7% of the 24-hour period on 9/14, violating the recycling specifications. |
Operational controls at the Consolidated Treatment Facility cause the plant to automatically divert Membrane Bioreactor (MBR) effluent to the Emergency Storage Basin if the turbidity Recycling Specifications are not met. However, during preparation of the August 2023 eSMR, it was discovered that these operational controls had temporarily been disabled for scheduled operational testing at the Consolidated Treatment Facility in ongoing efforts to prepare it for discharging to the San Joaquin River. Though the controls were re-enabled once this discovery was made, it was later discovered that PLC/SCADA programming was needed to fully rectify the turbidity exceedances. This programming issue was resolved on October 12, 2023, and the controls have since been re-enabled. Review of operational data since resolution of the programming issue indicates that these controls are currently functioning as intended. Despite these turbidity challenges, the Consolidated Treatment Facility continued to achieve adequate disinfection, with effluent Total Coliform measuring <1.8 MPN/100mL on September 14th, 2023. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1121483 |
09/13/2023 |
Order Conditions |
Filter effluent turbidity exceeded 0.2 NTU for 9% of the 24-hour period on 9/13, violating the recycling specifications. |
Operational controls at the Consolidated Treatment Facility cause the plant to automatically divert Membrane Bioreactor (MBR) effluent to the Emergency Storage Basin if the turbidity Recycling Specifications are not met. However, during preparation of the August 2023 eSMR, it was discovered that these operational controls had temporarily been disabled for scheduled operational testing at the Consolidated Treatment Facility in ongoing efforts to prepare it for discharging to the San Joaquin River. Though the controls were re-enabled once this discovery was made, it was later discovered that PLC/SCADA programming was needed to fully rectify the turbidity exceedances. The programming issue was resolved on October 12, 2023, and the controls have since been re-enabled. Review of operational data since resolution of the programming issue indicates that these controls are currently functioning as intended. Despite these turbidity challenges, the Consolidated Treatment Facility continued to achieve adequate disinfection, with effluent Total Coliform measuring <1.8 MPN/100mL on September 13, 2023. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
1120672 |
08/27/2023 |
Order Conditions |
Filter effluent turbidity exceeded 0.2 NTU for 25% of the 24-hour period on 8/27, violating the recycling specifications. |
Operational controls at the Consolidated Treatment Facility cause the plant to automatically divert MBR effluent to the Emergency Storage Basin if the turbidity Recycling Specifications are not met. However, it was discovered that these operational controls had been temporarily disabled for scheduled operational testing at the Consolidated Treatment Facility in ongoing efforts to prepare it for discharging to the San Joaquin River. These controls have since been re-enabled. Despite these turbidity challenges, the Consolidated Treatment Facility continued to achieve adequate disinfection, with effluent Total Coliform measuring <1.8 MPN/100mL on August 27, 2023. |
Violation |
B |
eSMR |
Report displays most recent five years of violations. Refer to the Interactive Violation Report for more data.
|